Alternatives North is expressing their concern about the winding down of the environmental oversight bodies for several mines in the territory.
In decisions released on June 30 and July 31, the Minister of Environment and Climate Change made the decision to begin the wind down process for the independent oversight bodies for the Snap Lake and Diavik diamond mines.
Alternatives North says that this decision was made without input from the public. They also express concern that the oversight body for the Ekati diamond mine may also begin winding down as the mine enters receivership.
“We disagree with the Minister’s decision and question how the public interest has been served. Independent oversight of large projects has been a hallmark of NWT environmental management for over 20 years,” said Alternatives North spokesperson Kevin O’Reilly.
Alternatives North also points out inconsistencies in the Minister’s decisions. The decision for Snap Lake mine, which ceased production in 2015, allows monitoring to continue until 2030, while the Diavik decision calls for the Environmental Monitoring Advisory Board to conclude its activities by March 31, 2027, only one year after the end of production at the mine.
The Minister’s decision on Diavik says that the board was consulted on the decision and they advocated for their work to continue through closure and post closure, along with letters of support from the North Slave Métis Alliance and the Kitikmeot Inuit Association.
The Tłı̨chǫ Government and Yellowknives Dene First Nation were also consulted, and supported a transitional wind down period, rather than an abrupt halt to monitoring.
“This approach recognizes the reduced need for EMAB’s oversight role through the transition to closure, given the mature, integrated co-management system that has developed in the Northwest Territories since 2000,” said Minister Jay Macdonald in the decision.
The Minister also says that the board’s concerns will be sufficiently addressed through Diavik’s Traditional Knowledge Monitoring Framework and ongoing bi-lateral engagement.
Alternatives North raises concerns about Diavik being put in charge of establishing a fund for independent technical review of its closure operations by Indigenous governments, rather than the GNWT taking this responsibility.
“[The] GNWT has not proven itself as a responsible resource manager with repeated receiverships, public liabilities and contaminated sites,” said O’Reilly.
“It’s time for the Auditor General of Canada to be called in to do a performance audit. We need to do much better.”




